When Cayden moves into his new apartment, he's happy that he'll finally be on his own, but his mother tries to convince him that it's a bad idea. Luckily for him, Cayden's father steps in and convinces her to let Cayden stay.

When his parents are gone, Cayden decides to get a little crazy and run around the house in his underwear, but when he finds Devon James in his apartment, he is shocked when he pulls him into the hall and locks him out in just his underwear.

Standing in the hall, Cayden meets an inebriated Gage Matthews, who offers him some marijuana, then tells him to go see Kathryn Hayes and ask if he can climb on her fire escape to get back inside his apartment.

When Cayden meets Kathryn, he finds that she's a little crazed and talks on and on about nothing in particular. Making it safely back into his apartment unscathed, Cayden finds Jesse Martinez there waiting for him.

Jesse tells Cayden that his ex-girlfriend, Julia Taylor was killed in his apartment, making Cayden's newfound independence bitter-sweet. Before Jesse leaves, he tells Cayden that he had a dream about Julia and she told him that Cayden would help find her killer.

When Cayden's parents return, they give him a cat because he has rats in his apartment. Cayden names the cat Mr. Rocky Balboa.

Later that day, Cayden decides to rearrange furniture and enlists the help of Gage Matthews. As they are moving a couch, Cayden discovers a loose floorboard and undearneath finds a diary and a bunch of letters from Julia Taylor.

Cayden refuses to give Gage or Kathryn Julia's diary or letters and instead calls the police and asks them to come pick up the letters. He runs into Devon at the incinerator chute and she tells him how Julia died, she was stabbed to death. When he tells Devon about the letters she requests that he hand them over to her, but he refuses and she gets angry and leaves.

Heading downstairs to do some laundry in the mean time, Cayden runs into Jesse, who shows him how to do laundry. Jesse tells Cayden that he knows that Cayden is gay, and after initially denying it, Cayden finally admits that it is true. When Cayden tells Jesse about the letters, Jesse agrees that the police should have them because he believes that Julia's killer still lives in the building.

After Jesse leaves, Cayden is attacked as someone tries to choke him with a rope. Able to break free, Cayden flees and runs into Szymon Skubisz. Szymon tries to apprehend the suspect and gets into a scuffle, but the suspect gets away with Szymon in pursuit. Cayden finds Jesse in the basement and Jesse tells him that someone hit him on the head from behind.

When Szymon returns he tells them that the attacker got away. They go up to Cayden's apartment where Cayden hands over Julia's letters, but secretly keeps her diary.

Two weeks after moving into his apartment, Cayden is fed up with Devon james and her careless disregard for her neighbors. When he tries to confront her, she gets defensive and Cayden, unable to find the courage to stand up to her, backs off. Later, Gage tells Cayden that he needs to put Devon in her place, but when presented with another opportunity to say something to her, Cayden shuts down.

At school, Cayden and another student, Elijah Montessori, are asked to stay after class by Professor Hirsch. The man tells them that their papers are incredible and suggests that they are plagiarized, but Cayden and Elijah both state that they wrote the papers themselves. Afterward, Cayden meets the president of the Gay Straight Alliance, Dominick Perrotti, but declines to join the group.

When he returns home, Gage invites Cayden to a party and while Cayden is getting ready, he has a talk with Kathryn Hayes as she sits on the fire escape. The two admit that they're kind of lonely without their family and Kathryn tells Cayden that he shouldn't keep his window open or something might try to steal his things.

At the party, Cayden runs into Dominick and they get drunk together, but when Dominick makes a move on Cayden, he freezes him out and decides to leave the party.

When he returns home, Cayden finds himself on the elevator with Devon James and finally goes off on her for being such a bitch. But when they get to his apartment, Cayden realizes that it's been burglarized. When Szymon Skubisz and his partner Cecilia Nakamura show up and ask Cayden what the burglar was after, Cayden realizes that he still has Julia Taylor's diary.

He tells Devon and together they decide to keep it a secret from the police so that they can read the diary and try to find Julia's killer themselves.

When Cayden beings to receive ominious phone calls, he thinks they are a joke at first, but as they continue, he starts to wonder if maybe one of this neighbors is trying to scare him. First, there is Devon, then Gage. Each of them seems capable of making those phone calls.

At school, Cayden runs into Dominick Perrotti and receives an apology, then Elijah Montessori asks Cayden if he can spend the night while his roommate entertains a lady friend. Cayden agrees.

When Cayden returns to his apartment, he finds an ominous letter and a surprise in the bathroom. Mr. Rocky Balboa is dead in the bathtub with a kitchen knife lodged in his side.

After calling Szymon, Cayden gets an earful from Devon, who tells him to keep the diary a secret while he freaks out, but he eventually agrees. When Szymon shows up, he tries to get Cayden to tell him the truth because he suspects that Cayden is lying about something, but Cayden doesn't relent.

When Szymon offers to spend the night and make sure that Cayden is okay, Elijah Montessori shows up and Cayden tells Szymon that there's no need for him to stay. Szymon leaves, albeit begrudgingly.

While doing laundry, Cayden is cornered by Jesse, who asks if he's found anything else of Julia's. When Cayden tells him that he hasn't, Jesse gets incresingly more disturbing and offers to go through Cayden's apartment to look for anything that may have belonged to Julia. Cayden manages to get away from Jesse, but not before Jesse apologizes.

Heading up to his apartment, Cayden runs into Kathryn, who tells him that he needs to change his style and offers to go shopping with him and Devon. Afterwards, Cayden is happy to find that his best friend, Mason Weber is waiting for him, but unfortunately for Cayden, Mason and Gage have hit it off and are carrying on like old friends.

When he is convinced to go to a bar, Cayden is at first annoyed, but after running into Dominick Perrotti, he lightens up. While Cayden goes to the bathroom, Dominick slips a drug into his drink. In the bathroom, Cayden runs into Szymon and they have a chat. But when Cayden is attacked by a drunk, Szymon knocks the guys out. Later, Szymon drinks from the same drugged bottle that was given to Cayden, but is successful in getting Cayden away from Dominick.

Taking Cayden back to his apartment, Szymon agrees to stay the night, but when Cayden wakes up, he realizes that neither he, nor Szymon are wearing any clothes.

Cayden whines to Devon and Mason about his night with Szymon Skubisz and the fact that he can't remember losing his virginity. They tell him that he needs to get over it and move on and then convince him to go out for Halloween.

After an awkward run-in with Szymon outside the costume shop, Cayden decides to dress as a vampire for Halloween but when Devon put her spin on his costume, he has second thoughts.

When everyone convinces him that he looks great, he decides to go out and is a hit with the guys. When he finds himself in a situation with an extremely attractive man, he's greatful when Mason intervenes, but when Devon decides that everyone should return to Cayden's apartment, they are shocked to find out that Devon has planned a seance and hopes to contact Julia Taylor.

Cayden agrees to go along with Devon's seance after some arguing. He has a conversation with Jesse in which he learns that Julia wanted to have many children, and tries to console his friend. During the seance, Cayden is scared when the ouija board tells everyone that he has Julia's diary. When the lights go off during the seance, Cayden agrees to go to the basement with Devon to turn them back on but is separated from her and runs into Kathryn, who tells him that Devon is probably the one who killed Julia.

Later, Cayden go back to his apartment and begins to read Julia's diary, where he discovers that Julia Taylor was pregnant.

Cayden tells Mason that Jesse scares him sometimes, but when Mason tells him that Jesse is basically harmless, Cayden tells him that he's not sure what Jesse is capable of. Later, he runs into Devon, who wants to read Julia's diary, but he avoids her and runs into Jesse. The two share an awkward conversation and then calls Szymon and asks if they can meet.

Szymon discovers that Cayden is still pursuing information about Julia and warns him to back off but realizes that Cayden isn't going to listen. He tells Cayden some very interesting secrets about his neighbors and when Cayden asks him if he knew of Julia's pregnancy, Szymon informs him that Julia wasn't pregnant when she died, she had already aborted the fetus.

Later, Cayden runs into Gage on the subway and when they head home, Gage tells Cayden that Devon's recent behavior can only be attributed to Cayden's presence because when Cayden arrived Devon started to act sneaky, like she was hiding something and feared that she would be caught. Their conversation is sidetracked, however, when they see Jesse being carted from the building by paramedics. Kathryn informs them that Jesse tried to take his own life so that he could be with Julia again.

Cayden and Gage decide to visit Gage in the hospital and one the way there, run into Szymon. Szymon and Cayden have a brief conversation before parting ways. When Cayden runs into Kathryn, he relaizes that she is upset and after some discussion, learns that she feels guilty for what happened to Jesse. Cayden assures her that it isn't her fault.

Cayden and Kathryn enter Jesse's room and find Devon there. Angry at Jesse for what he did, Devons rips into him and then exits the room, followed by Kathryn. While alone, Cayden and Jesse have a discussion about what happened and Cayden manages to convince Jesse that if Julia loved him as much as he believes she did, that she would want him to live his life to the fullest.

Later, Szymon enters Jesse's room and accused him of attempting suicide because he felt guilty about killing Julia. Cayden rushes to Jesse's defense and tells Szymon that he is disappointed in him.

Afterwards, Cayden and Devon head home and run into Mrs. Mulberry, who tells them that they need to watch out for Kathryn Hayes because she is up to something. Devon asks Cayden what he is doing for Thanksgiving and the two decide to host a get together and invite Jesse.

As Cayden heads to his apartment, he runs into Elijah, who begs him to let him stay the night. Cayden reluctantly accepts and shares his bed with Elijah. In the middle of the night, Cayden awakens and realizes that Elijah is sleeping with his arms around him. Content with being held, even if just for one night, Cayden goes back to sleep.

When Cayden wakes up, Elijah is gone. Cayden decides to take a peek at Julia's diary and reads a passage in which Julia Taylor admits to having an affair and cheating on Jesse Martinez.

On Thanksgiving, everyone has gathered at Cayden's apartment for dinner. While preparing the food, Devon and Mason tease Cayden about Elijah sleeping in his bed and Devon suggests that Cayden take initiative and see if a relationship with Elijah would be possible. Cayden cuts his finger while slicing carrots and Elijah tends to the cut. Sexual tension builds and Elijah tells Cayden that he would like to talk about something, but they are interrupted by Gage and Elijah decides to hold off on telling Cayden.

Later, Kathryn helps Cayden prepare dinner. Still thinking about Julia's diary entry in which she admitted to cheating on Jesse, Cayden asks her about that relationship and Kathryn confirms that they were very close but did have an argument a few months before Julia died in which Jesse accused her of cheating on him after receiving an anonymous letter.

Mason tells everyone that one of their neighbors is dead after having committed suicide and everyone shows concern for how Jesse reacts to this news, but he assured them that he is fine and that he knows he would have ended up like their neighbor if he didn't have such great friends.

As they are about to sit down to dinner, Szymon shows up and asks to speak with Cayden. He apologizes to Cayden for what happened in the hospital and admits that he's confused by his feelings for Cayden. When Cayden asks him why, Szymon kisses him. However, Elijah enters the room and tells Cayden that he would like to sleep on the right side of the bed tonight. Szymon gets the wrong impression. Embarrassed, he excuses himself and leaves the apartment.

When everyone sits down to dinner, they tell one another what they are most thankful for and Cayden admits that he is thankful that he has his new friends.

It is two weeks after Thanksgiving, and as the day begins everyone is helping Mason move into his new apartment, the apartment in which a neighbor of Cayden's committed suicide. When everyone begins to get tired of cleaning the new apartment, they decide to take a break. Cayden, Devon, Gage, Jesse, and Kathryn head to the corner store to pick up some snacks. While they are there, Szymon enters the store and speaks to Cayden privately, or so they think

When Szymon tells Cayden that they are officially labeling Julia's murder as a cold case, Devon reacts strongly. When everyone finds out what Szymon told Cayden, Cayden realizes that it would be best for Szymon to leave, and he does so.

As everyone decides to pay for their snacks and leave, a man with a gun enters the corner store and tells the cashier to hand over the money. When the cashier pulls out a shotgun, things go from bad to worse. The cashier is shot and killed and another customer who tries to flee is shot as well.

Outside, Szymon hears the gunshots and orders the store robber to come out, but the man doesn't comply. He holds Cayden, Devon, Gage, Jesse and Kathryn hostage, threatening to kill them.

When Jesse sees an opportunity to tackle the gunman, he takes it, but is overpowered by the other man. In the struggle to get free, Gage is shot. When Cayden sees that, he tries to flee but is held by the gunman. In an effort to get out of the store, the gunman holds a gun to Cayden's head and threatens to shoot him. Szymon sees that and loses it. When Szymon doesn't back off, the gunman shoots Cayden on the arm.

Huddled together, Cayden and Gage start to talk and Cayden realizes that Gage is losing consciousness so he tries to get Gage to talk so that he can stay awake. As Gage drifts into unconsciousness, he tells Cayden that he had sex with Julia Taylor.

Cayden is shocked by the revelation, but quickly realizes that he has to get out of the store before he is killed. He tries to flee but if caught by the gunman and is thrown into the center of a standoff with the gunman and the police. With quick thinking, Cayden is able to briefly incapacitate the gunman, allowing Szymon a clear shot, which he takes.

Before going to school, Cayden sees Jesse and Mason searching for themselves on Google. Cayden wants to search for Szymon Skubisz and they tease him about being in love with him. When it seems as if Mason is more interested in the internet than getting to work on time, Cayden has to drag him out of the apartment.

At school, Dominick Perrotti approaches Cayden and asks him out on a date. When Cayden asks him why, Dominick tells him that he decided that if he didn't take a chance, he might miss an opportunity for something good. Cayden refuses when he realizes that he needs to do exactly what Dominick told him, take a chance at being with Szymon Skubisz.

After searching for Szymon on Google, Cayden finds his address and shows up at his place where he meets a beautiful woman and a young boy. Much to his shock, Cayden discovers that the boy is Szymon's son and the woman is Szymon's wife. He leaves the apartment quickly.

On the street, Cayden runs into Szymon and Szymon tries to explain his situation, but Cayden doesn't want to hear it and leaves.

Cayden is depressed over finding out that Szymon is married and he tries to go to his friends for help. Unfortunately for him, all of his friends are either hooking up or going on dates and don't have much time for him. When he sees couple after couple, Cayden begins to get sad.

Eventually, he runs into Elijah Montessori in a coffee shop and takes a chance, asking Elijah on a date. When Elijah declines, Cayden is crushed and later spies Elijah at the table with a cute blond guy, realizing that Elijah was on a date as well.

Just when he is about to give up, Cayden runs into Dominick Perrotti, who says all the right things and invites Cayden on a date, which Cayden accepts.

It's Christmas Eve, and while trying to get ready for a date with Dominick Perrotti, Devon shows up at Cayden's apartment. Cayden tries to rush her out but feels sympathetic when she starts to talk about missing Julia. He tells her that she needs to go out and have fun, for her and for Julia, and she agrees.

When Gage pops into Cayden's apartment, he tries to get Cayden to hang out with him for the night. Cayden declines and says that he has plans and Gage begins to tease him about being a slut.

Later, Cayden spies Kathryn and Jesse on the fire escape and is worried because he doesn't want them there when Dominick shows up. They invite him to go out with them, but he declines.

When Dominick finally shows up, he puts the moves on Cayden, but another interruption, this time from Elijah Montessori, causes them to stop. Elijah reacts strongly to Dominick's presence and leaves, but not before telling Cayden to be careful.

Later, Cayden is surprised when Szymon Skubisz shows up with a bouquet of roses. When Szymon sees Dominick, he realizes that he's missed his chance with Cayden and leaves.

As Cayden and Dominick begin to have sex, Cayden finds that it's not exactly what he imagined it to be. Dominick is rough and Cayden asks him to stop, but Dominick continues. Finally, when Dominick begins to reach his climax, Cayden is relieved, but his relief is short-lived when his parents surprise him by jumping into his bedroom at the most inopportune time.

After Cayden's parents walk in on his having sex with Dominick Perrotti, he sits down and has a talk with them. When his father tells him that he needs to come back home, Cayden refuses, causing his parents to disown him and leave.

Later, Cayden is feeling sad and decides to get drunk. Jesse tries to talk to him and convince him that getting drunk isn't the answer and Cayden argues with him, ultimately they go to their separate corners.

When Devon catches Jesse kissing Kathryn, she explodes and everyone gets involved in an argument. When Gage tells everyone that Julia wouldn't have wanted them to argue because she was all about forgiveness, Cayden lets it slip that Gage slept with Julia and Jesse forgave her for that.

A stunned Jesse didn't know that Gage was the one Julia cheated on his with and tries to attack him. As they try to figure out how Cayden knew about the affair, Devon tells them that he has Julia's diary and she demands that Cayden give it to her because he can't be trusted.

Angry, Cayden turns on Devon and tells her that she's the one who can't be trusted because she helped Julia secretly get an abortion when she didn't know if Gage or Jesse was her baby's father.

This knews causes everyone to go into shock and leave Cayden's apartment, but not before Devon punches him on the nose.

After learning that Dominick Perrotti only wanted him for sex, Cayden decides to go out for New Year's Eve. When the power goes out, leaving him stuck in an elevator with Devon, the two have it out over what happened on Christmas. Cayden tells her that he can't be held responsible for ruining Julia's memory because her memory was a lie that Devon helped protect. After some heated words, Devon forgives him and tells him that it's not his fault, he just got caught in the middle of everything. When the power returns, they decide not to go out and spend the holiday together.

While they are heading up the stairs, they run into Gage, who tries to avoid them, but Devon stops him and tells him that they are not mad at him. After some convincing, Gage agrees to spend New Year's Eve with them.

When Cayden returns to his apartment with Devon and Gage, he spies Kathryn and Jesse on the fire escape and opens the window. Jesse tries to ignore him and go back into Kathryn's apartment, but Cayden stops him and asks him if knowing who Julia cheated with changes the fact that he forgave her for doing it. When Jesse realizes that he still loved Julia even when he didn't know who she cheated on his with, he realizes that Cayden is right, but he is still angry at Gage. At Cayden's request, Jesse and Kathryn enter his apartment.

Later, Cayden retreats to his bedroom to have some alone time, but Devon interrupts him and talks to him about Julia. She tells him that she feels responsible for Julia's death because she gave her bad advice. Julia received a letter around the same time that Jesse received the letter that clued him into her affair. Julia's letter demanded that she break up with Jesse and Devon told her to ignore the letter.

As the countdown to midnight begins, everyone gathers in Cayden's living room. When the clock strikes twelve, they cheer and Cayden is thankful that he spent the evening with his friends, but a knock at the door takes him by surprise, and when he opens it, Szymon Skubisz grabs him and kisses him in front of everyone. When he pulls away, he tells Cayden that he didn't want to start the new year without any regrets.

Cayden and Devon discuss his plans for lunch with Szymon, and Devon teases him about being a home-wrecker. Cayden confesses his hesitance to get involved with a married man, but Devon convinces him to at least meet with Szymon.

At school, Cayden runs into Elijah and is told that Dominick Perrotti is spreading rumors about him. Dominick told several people that Cayden was a freak in bed. Elijah then asks Cayden if he could move in with him. Elijah confesses that he lives with his brother and shares a room with his nephews. Cayden realizes that he will need help to pay the rent since his parents cut him off, so he decides to take Elijah up on his offer.

When Cayden walks into the student lounge, he spots Dominick and gets embarrassed, but when people start laughing about him because of the rumors that Dominick is spreading, Cayden gets angry. Without saying a word, Cayden punches Dominick in the face and leaves.

At lunch, Cayden tells Szymon that Elijah is moving in. Szymon admits that he is jealous of Elijah and Cayden tells Szymon that he's jealous of Andrea. Szymon tells Cayden the entire story about how he and Andrea are best friends and he donated sperm so that she could get preganant. He tells Cayden that they only got married because Andrea was sick and needed an operation, but didn't have proper medical insurance.

When Cayden hears the truth, he is relieved and Szymon confesses that he would like to kiss Cayden, but when Cayden moves in for the kiss, Szymon pulls back. Szymon tells Cayden that he doesn't want to kiss in public because he isn't out of the closet yet, but he invited Cayden to the bathroom of the restaurant so that they could make out in private.

Deciding that he would rather not hide the fact that he is gay, Cayden declines and leaves the restaurant.

When he gets home, Cayden runs into Jesse, who admits that he is having a problem with Kathryn. Jesse feels as if he is being unfaithful to Julia because he is attracted to Kathryn. Cayden tells him that it's going to take time and that it's normal for him to feel that way.

Kathryn approaches them and tells Cayden that Jesse is having his artwork featured at an art show.

Later, Gage pulls Cayden into his apartment to confess the fact that he has feelings for Devon. Cayden laughs and tells him that he either needs to own up to his feelings and tell Devon, or he can ignore them and hope that they go away.

Finally able to get back to his apartment, Cayden walks in on Elijah sleeping on the couch naked. In the next few awkward moments, Cayden realizes that his boyfriend won't kiss him in public and his roommate walks around naked.

It is the night of Jesse's big art show and Cayden is disappointed because he believes that Szymon is not going to show up. Devon talks to him and tells him that despite the fact that she doesn't like Szymon, she believes that he is a man of his word and if he said he'd show up, then he will.

Trying to get his mind off of Szymon, Cayden gives Gage advice about Devon. He tells him to talk to her and see where things go. Later, Kathryn approaches Cayden and he vents about his frustrations with Szymon. She assures him that everything is going to be fine and if things don't work out with Szymon, she has a few gay friends that are interested.

When Szymon finally shows up, Cayden is happy, but when he sees Andrea Darling at Szymon's side, he gets worried. Cayden realizes that Andrea is there with Cecilia Nakamura and is relieved. Szymon professes his devotion to Cayden and tells him that he wants to be with him. Szymon then kisses Cayden in front of everyone.

When the host of the evening announces that it is time to reveal Jesse's final painting, things go badly when Jesse unveils a portrait of Julia that has been vandalized. Jesse tears out of the show, screaming.

While Szymon and Cecilia try to figure out what's going on, Andrea approaches Cayden and tells him that Szymon really wants to be with himand she asks Cayden to promise her that he'll be patient with Szymon because Szymon isn't used to being out of the closet. Cayden agrees.

Later, When Szymon admits that he feel like a failure for being unable to catch Julia's killer, Cayden admits that he kept Julia's diary. Szymon comes down on Cayden pretty hard over keeping the diary, but apologizes and warns Cayden that if people know that he has Julia's diary, his life could be in danger again. They decide to go to Cayden's apartment to retrieve the diary.

When they show up, they find Elijah having sex in Cayden's bed, but even more shocking, Cayden realizes that the diary is missing and comes to the conclusion that someone stole Julia Taylor's diary from his apartment.

Cayden and Elijah Montessori discover that they plan on applying for the same job at a gay maagazine called Inside OUT. Cayden is at first hesitant, but agrees that they should still both apply for the job. The two even decide to make a game out of it, and tease each other about who is going to get the job.

When they arrive at Inside OUT, Cayden finds himself in awe. As they are filling out applications, Elijah catches the eye of the human resources guy and sneaks off into a closet to have sex with him. Left alone, Cayden wanders around and finds an unhappy woman in the lounge. She unloads all of her problems on him and he does his best to help her sort through them. At the end of the conversation, she offers to put a good word in with human resources for him.

Later, Cayden meets up with Szymon and Sammy in the park and Szymon tells Cayden that he's happy that Sammy feels comfortable with him because he usually has a hard time meeting new people. As the two playfully flirt, Sammy falls and breaks his arm.

At the hospital, Cayden is happy to find out that Sammy will be fine. Szymon is equally relieved and kisses Cayden. When Szymon pulls away, he locks eyes with a police officer and quickly walks off, leaving Cayden standing there by himself.

It's Valentine's Day and as the day begins, Cayden tries to show Elijah how to cook, with disastrous results. When Elijah recieves a call from Insight OUT Magazine, he is excited because they want to hire him as their movie reviewer.

Devon drops by to vent her frustrations with Gage. She tells Cayden that she's confused because she doesn't want to have feelings for Gage, but she does. Cayden tells her that she needs to do something about it, but Devon chooses to avoid the situation instead.

Later, Cayden finds Jesse and Kathryn in the laundry room and asks Jesse if he's okay. Jesse admits that he realized that Julia is gone for good and he has to move on. He admits to Cayden that he is going to make love to Kathryn for the first time. When Sarah Mulberry enters, she asks everyone what they're doing and seems especially interested in Jesse.

When Szymon finally shows up, he tells Cayden that he is completely out of the closet. He tells Cayden that they can go out and hold hands and kiss one another in public, but Cayden opts to stay in and the two make love. Afterwards, Szymon gives Cayden his ring. The ring is too big for Cayden's finger, but he keeps it anyway.

Cayden is frantic when he loses the ring tht Szymon gave him while throwing out the trash. He begs Devon and Elijah for their help in searching for it and the three go down to the incinerator to wade through trash bags. As the search becomes futile, Cayden discovers a trash bag filled with pictures of Julia Taylor. They find Julia's diary that was stolen from Cayden's apartment. The three soon realize that they just dug through the trash of Julia's killer. They take the trash bag with them as they scurry to leave, Cayden finds the ring at the last moment.

Back in Cayden's apartment, he gathers everyone and tells them about the findings. Cayden calls Szymona d asks him to get there right away. As Jesse steps forward the grab the bag, Kathryn blocks him and grabs it. Devon is furious that Kathryn continues to further contaminate the evidence. Cayden tries to bring everyone back to their senses and they agree to go through the bad while wearing latex gloves.

While they are searching through the bag, Cayden gets overwhelmed and steps into his bedroom. Devon follows him and asks if he is okay. Cayden admits that he's scared at the fact that there is a killer in the building who has broken into his apartment on several ocassions. Devon admits to Cayden that she is scared too. She also admits that she is pregnant.

As Jesse Martinez searched through the bag of evidence, he is shocked to find that in every picture of Julia Taylor, someone cut out her eyes. When Gage tries to help, Jesse goes off on him, blaming him for preventing him from spending precious time with Julia before she died. Kathryn does her best to stop the two men from fighting and Jesse becomes frustrated that he can't find anything in the bag.

When Cecilia Nakamura and Szymon Skubisz arrive to pick up the bag of evidence left by Julia's killer, they are shocked that everyone rifled through the bag. As Cecilia goes through the evidence, she notes that someone took photographs of Julia inside of her apartment from the fire escape. Cecilia finds a picture in the bag that is different from the rest. Cayden is present in the photograph, which means that it was taken after Julia died, and furthermore, Jesse Martinez is cut out of the picture. Cayden admits that he took the picture at Christmas and made a copy for all of his friends.

During a quiet moment, Cayden and Elijah both express their fears for what will happen and Elijah tries his best to reassure his friend that everyone will work out.

When Mason enters Cayden's apartment, Sarah follows him. The two of them find out about the bag in the incinerator and Sarah makes a few catty remarks that get Devon's blood boiling and Devon attacks her. Their fight spills out into the corridor, but it is eventually broken up my the men and Mrs. Mulberry.

Back at the police station, Cecilia and Szymon pore over the evidence and Szymon has a thought about one of the pictures. He calls Cayden and tells him to gather everyone and make them go get their copy of the photograph. Cayden quickly realizes that whoever doesn't have their copy of the picture is the killer.

With the power out, Cayden finds himself all alone. After asking Devon to go bring back her picture he waits, but the darkness soon begins to frighten him and he starts off to search for Devon. Cayden gets scared when he runs into Mason and asks him what he's doing. Mason asks if he can borrow Cayden's digital camera and Cayden agrees if Mason waits for him to get back from turning to power back on in the basement. Mason agrees and Cayden leaves the apartment.

In the basement of the apartment building, Cayden searches for the breaker switch in the darkness. As he is searching, Devon James appears and Cayden notices that she is acting a little strange. Devon admits to finding Mason dead in Cayden's apartment, and Cayden realizes that she is holding a bloody knife. Cayden begins to fear for his life and realizes that Devon is the killer, but Szymon Skubisz shows up in time to protect Cayden. He points his gun at Devon and demands that she surrender.

When Gage Matthews arrives in the basement, he is shocked to find Szymon weilding a gun on Devon as Cayden stands by and watches. Gage shields Devon from Szymon's gun and the four invidiuals find themselves in a standoff. Cayden accuses Devon of killing Mason and Gage denies that she had anything to do with it. Devon continues to try to get Cayden to listen to her words. Gage is ultimately successful in retrieving the knife from Devon, but Devon pushes forward and reaches into her jacket for something.

Szymon is poised to shoot, but Cayden stops him by telling everyone that Devon is pregnant. When Devon pulls out a piece of paper and hands it to Cayden, he is confused at first until he realizes that it is the picture he gave her. She still had it. Devon collapses to the ground and everyone realizes that she has been stabbed in the back.

Szymon and Cayden arrive just in time to watch Cecilia being pushed off of the fire escape. They share tense words and Kathryn fires her gun on Cayden, causing him to stumble into the hall. Szymon rushes to his side and Kathryn slams the door shut.

Szymon kicks the door to Cayden's apartment down and finds Jesse standing there, holding the gun to his head. With the help of Cayden, Gage and Devon, Szymon is successful in getting Jesse to drop the gun. A defeated Jesse falls to the floor, a sobbing mess.

Szymon tells Cecilia that she will be alright as she is taken away in an ambulance. He then discusses Elijah's condition with Cayden. It seems that there was extensive damage to Elijah's head and they hope that he will be okay.