and Cayden are held after class to discuss their papers with Professor Hirsch. When the professor tells them that their papers are incredible, and Cayden tell one another that they were valedictorian's of their senior class in highschool.

Later, runs into Dominick Perrotti, the president of the Gay Straight Alliance and the two make a wager on who will sleep with Cayden King first.

approaches Cayden in the student lounge int he gusie of getting together to study. When Cayden sees through his attempt, admits that he doesn't have a place to stay for the night because his roommate is having a lady friend over and wants him gone. Cayden agrees to let spend the night at his place. Afterwards, tells Dominick Perrotti that he's close to getting Cayden into bed and winning the fifty dollars.

When shows up at Cayden's he finds out that Cayden's cat was killed so he goes out and gets Chinese food and rents some movies to make Cayden feel better.

On Thanksgiving, everyone has gathered at Cayden's apartment for dinner. Cayden cuts his finger while slicing carrots and tends to the cut. Sexual tension builds and tells Cayden that he would like to talk about something, but they are interrupted by Gage and decides to hold off on telling Cayden.

Unbeknownst to , he interrupts a moment between Cayden and Szymon when he enters the room and tells Cayden that he would like to sleep on the right side of the bed tonight. Szymon gets the wrong impression. Embarrassed, he excuses himself and leaves the apartment.

When everyone sits down to dinner, they tell one another what they are most thankful for and admits that he is thankful that he always has a place to go whenever he needs it.

At school, Cayden runs into and is told that Dominick Perrotti is spreading rumors about him. Dominick told several people that Cayden was a freak in bed. then asks Cayden if he could move in with him. confesses that he lives with his brother and shares a room with his nephews. Cayden realizes that he will need help to pay the rent since his parents cut him off, so he decides to take up on his offer.

When Cayden returns to his apartment later in the day, he walks in on sleeping on the couch naked. In the next few awkward moments, tries to apoligize and explains that he feels more comfortable being naked. Cayden tells him that it's fine and excuses himself to retreat to his bedroom.

Cayden and Montessori discover that they plan on applying for the same job at a gay maagazine called Inside OUT. Cayden is at first hesitant, but agrees that they should still both apply for the job. The two even decide to make a game out of it, and tease each other about who is going to get the job.

When they arrive at Inside OUT, Cayden finds himself in awe. As they are filling out applications, catches the eye of the human resources guy and sneaks off into a closet to have sex with him.

When Devon returns home from grocery shopping, she is accompanied by , who helps her carry her groceries. tells her about his sexual escapades and she teases him about it.

Cayden is frantic when he loses the ring that Szymon gave him while throwing out the trash. He begs Devon and Elijah for their help in searching for it and the three go down to the incinerator to wade through trash bags. As the search becomes futile, Cayden discovers a trash bag filled with pictures of Julia Taylor. They find Julia's diary that was stolen from Cayden's apartment. The three soon realize that they just dug through the trash of Julia's killer. They take the trash bag with them as they scurry to leave, Cayden finds the ring at the last moment.

During a quiet moment, Cayden and Elijah both express their fears for what will happen and tries his best to reassure his friend that everyone will work out.

When Mason enters Cayden's apartment, Sarah follows him. The two of them find out about the bag in the incinerator and Sarah makes a few catty remarks that get Devon's blood boiling and Devon attacks her. Their fight spills out into the corridor, but it is eventually broken up by the men and Mrs. Mulberry. Mason and Elijah decide to go for a drink.

When Elijah returns to Cayden's apartment, he is shocked to find Mason's dead body. As he stumbles out of the bedroom, he runs into Kathryn and she tells him that Devon murdered Cayden and she saw the whole thing from where she was hiding in the bathroom. She tells him that when Devon left, she crawled out of the bathroom and checked to make sure that Cayden was okay but that when she checked his pulse he was dead. Realizing that something it wrong, Elijah tells Kathryn that it isn't Cayden who's dead, it's Mason. Elijah suddenly realizes that Kathryn is lying and tries to flee, but Kathryn prevents him from doing so by knocking him to the ground. She grabs Cayden's DVD player and slams it down on Elijah's head.

A badly beatean Elijah is taken to the hospital via ambulance. The extent of his injuries are unknown, as is the possibility that he will ever wake up again.