2x01: "Hello, Part I"

While heading for the subway, Gage is attacked by the enforcer of a bookie whom he owns money too. He is threatened and punched int he stomach. Sarah Mulberry finds him and asks him what happened and Gage declines to tell her.

Devon is upset when Sarah Mulberry arrives at Jesse's Welcome Home Party and the two share words. Cayden and Devon then get into an argument about their friendship, or lack thereof while tryign to set up for Jesse's party. The two have no idea that Jesse has shown up right in the middle of their argument. When Jesse tells everyone that he's seen Julia Taylor, they begin to think that maybe he is still crazy, but they are surprised when Jesse's grandmother, Liliana shows up and asks them all to leave and forbids them to ever have contact with Jesse again.

After leaving Jesse's, the group moves downstairs where Cayden and Devon's argument reaches boiling point. As they are arguing, Jesse rushes off of the elevator and tells everyone that he saw Julia again. They try to make his realize that Julia is dead, but then the elevator doors open and Julia Taylor steps off, surprising them all.2x03: "Secrets"

Joseph runs into Sarah Mulberry in the foyer on his way to meet Szymon. He helps Sarah pick up her mail from the floor and mistakenly believes that her name is Julia Taylor when he reads the name on one of the letters.

2x02: "Hello, Part II"

Everyone is shock when a woman who looks exactly like Julia Taylor steps off of the elevator. She introduces herself as Ryan Clarke. As Cayden watches, Jesse grabs her and gives her a hug. Ryan tries to get him off of her and is unsuccessful until her boyfriend Steven Harris arrives and pulls them apart. He threatens to hit Jesse but Cayden steps in and tries to defuse the situation with Mrs. Mulberry's help. Devon, in the meantime, discovers that the woman is telling the truth. She is not Julia Taylor. Everyone leaves after Jesse is taken back to his apartment by Gage and Elijah and Cayden is left alone to awkwardly welcome Ryan and Steven to the building. Later, Sarah visits Sebastian Vaughn and learns that he is a musician and plays the guitar.

2x03: "Secrets"

Sarah attempts to get Sebastian Vaughn into bed with disastrous results. Sebastian rejects her, but tells her that he'd still like to be her friend. A dejected Sarah instead walks off. Later, Joseph runs into Sarah Mulberry in the foyer on his way to meet Szymon. He helps Sarah pick up her mail from the floor and mistakenly believes that her name is Julia Taylor when he reads the name on one of the letters.

2x04: "What Might Have Been"

In this special episode, we get to see what life would have been like had Cayden King not moved into the building. Sarah Mulberry does not appear in this episode.

2x05: "Call Me"

Mrs. Mulberry informs her grandaughter that she needs to get a job and help pay the bills if she plans on living with her.

While doing laundry, Steven runs into Sarah Clarke and does his best to try and charm her, but Sarah seems uninterested and Steven departs. After he leaves, Sarah pulls out an envelope addressed to Julia Taylor from a place called Wellington Hills. She calls the telephone number for Wellington Hills and discovers that it is a mental institution.

She later asks both Jesse and Devon if they know anything about Wellington Hills and both are annoyed by her asking, but say they do not know the place.

2x06: "Free"

The group decides to go to Xstatic, a gay nightclub to celebrate Cayden's new job and Elijah not getting fired. When Sarah arrives at the nightclub, she marvels at all of the gorgeous men, but a jaded Devon reminds her that they are all gay.

While in the bathroom, Steven is surprised when Jesse arrives and warns him to leave Ryan alone. Jesse tells him that if he wants to hit someone, then he should stop hitting women and hit a man. When Steven puts up a fight, Jesse punches him and knocks him to the ground and warns him to stay away from Ryan. Jesse leaves the bathroom. Sarah Mulberry witnesses the altercation and begins to laugh at a beaten Steven, to which Steven become angry and lunges for her.

Before Steven can touch Sarah, a male stripper by the name of Vasilios Hatzis steps in and stops him.

2x07: "It's Too Late"

Sarah Mulberry watches all of the action going on in the hallway when her grandmother approaches her and tells her to get inside and give her all the juicy details.

When Sarah drops by Devon's apartment to discuss the night's affairs, Devon verbally abuses her and tells her that no one really likes her. She embarrasses Sarah to the point at which she gets up and leave, feeling unwanted.

2x08: "Last Night"

After being locked out of their apartments by the police, Cayden and Devon, along with Gage and Elijah meet in the stairwell of their building to discuss their current situation and what will happen if the police find evidence against them. Sarah walks in on the conversation and Devon admits to killing Luis Alvarez.

With some help from the others, Sarah ultimately agrees to keeping their secret, but not becuase she likes them, but because she doesn't want Devon's baby to grow up without a mother.

When Szymon Skubisz overhears the conversation, everyone is afraid of what he might do, but after letting everyone know exactly what he thinks of them and their lies, Szymon informs them that he loves Cayden and that is the only reason why he won't say anything.

2x09: "Together"

When Sarah breaks the news to her grandmother that she is going to start dating Joseph Lester, Mrs. Mulberry warns her against doing so. Sarah explains to her grandmother that the only reason she is doing so is to make sure that Joseph doesn't figure out what really happened to Luis Alvarez. Mrs. Mulberry tells her that she is playing with fire, but Sarah doesn't listen.

Later, Sarah goes to a grocery store to apply for a job. In fact, it was the same job that Cayden had before leaving for the magazine. Serena Sidhu decides to hire Sarah, even after she knocks things over and makes a complete fool out of herself.

After she leaves, she meets up with Ryan Clarke and they run into Joseph Lester and Szymon Skubisz. Joseph invites them to lunch and the four go to a diner where they run into Devon and Gage who were there waiting for Cayden and Elijah. They invite themselve to Devon's table. Soon others start to arrive.

When Devon announces that she and Gage are having a baby boy and naming him Taylor, after Julia Taylor, everyone drinks to a toast. They marvel at how they've managed to stay together despite all of the obstacles they've faced and they welcome anyone to try and break their little family apart.

2x10: "Strangers"

When Sarah Mulberry arrives at Jesse's apartment, she finds Sebastian Vaughn completely naked. Jesse's conversation with Sebastian is curtailed and Sebastian slinks away with embarrassment.

Jesse admits to Sarah that Sebastian admitted that he is in love with him and he doesn't know what to make of what Sebastian admitted, but Sarah gets him to stop thinking about it long enough to go with her to Victoria's party.

2x11: "Family Portrait"

When Sarah returns home, she finds her mother Cassandra Mulberry waiting for her with her grandmother. Sarah’s reaction to her mother’s presence surprises Mrs. Mulberry. Cassandra tells Sarah that it’s time for her to return home to Albany. Sarah objects to this strongly, but Cassandra is firm. Mrs. Mulberry tells Sarah that it’s probably the best decision, but stops when she sees Sarah is visible shaken. Cassandra and Sarah argue and when Sarah tries to leave, Cassandra tells Sarah that she’s always been a quitter.

Sarah finds herself at Jesse’s apartment. She vents her frustrations about her mother and asks him for his advice. Jesse listens sympathetically and urges her to talk to her mother honestly. Sarah considers his advice and makes a decision to help Jesse. She gives him the letter she found for Julia Taylor. Jesse is intrigued by the letter, but a knock at the door interrupts them. Sebastian enters. Sarah takes this as her cue to leave.

2x12: "Wait"

Sarah returns to the building to find Elijah and Nicolae still handing out in the lobby, trying to figure out what to do. She invites them upstairs and when they step into the apartment, the place is sparkling clean and smells like cookies. Sarah immediately knows what is going on. Cassandra Mulberry steps out of the kitchen with an apron, a smile, and a batch of fresh chocolate chip cookies. She asks the boys if they would like some and they do, of course. Sarah tells her mother to stop whatever it is she is up to. Cassandra addresses Sarah’s rude behavior in front of their guests.

2x13: "No One"

Mrs. Mulberry and Elijah Montessori arrive to find Sarah and Cassandra fighting one another. Cassandra tells Sarah that she should go to Albany with her to get away from the potential danger of being involved in a murder cover-up. Sarah declines to go with her and they continue to argue. A frightened Elijah, loses control of himself and Mrs. Mulberry interjects. She tells Cassandra to go. Before she leaves, Sarah tells Cassandra to never come back or she will regret it.

2x14: "Forget You"

While heading to his apartment, Cayden teases Sarah about her relationship with Joseph Lester, Szymon's partner. Sarah admits that she actually is starting to like him, but isn't sure where it's going.

2x15: "Liar"

Mrs. Mulberry watches New anchor Brian Chambers explain that there still are no leads in the murder of Luis Alvarez and feels relieved, but when she gets a call from Joseph Lester and agrees to take a message for Sarah that she purposely does not relay as to create tension between the two, she sees her opportunity to make sure that no one ever finds out. Sarah admits to her grandmother the possibility that she would like to see where this thing with Joseph goes.

Sarah is pissed off when Joseph arrives late for their dinner date and discovers that her grandmother is the reason. She also gives Joseph a hard time for making people think that they had sex when they never actually did. Joseph admits that he had to brag so people wouldn't think he was gay. Szymon is his partner and the other officers are starting to torment him because of Szymon's sexual preference.

2x16: "Strange Bedfellows"

Adam Price tells Sebastian that he is playing a very dangerous game when they run into one another in the foyer. Sebastian tells Adam that if he tells anyone about his past, he will reveal all of Adam's dirty little secrets. Their conversation ends in a stalemate as Sarah Mulberry enters. She admits to Sebastian that she also hasn't had much time with Jesse since he started with Ryan and she secretly disliked Ryan. They decide to watch a movie together to get their minds over missing their friend.

2x17: "Give Me One Reason"

Devon comes home from grocery shopping worried that something is wrong with Gage. He isn’t answering his phone and has actually put her through to voicemail. She demands that he call her back. Sarah offers to help a struggling Devon with the grocery bags and they step onto the elevator together. When the power goes out and the two women are stuck in the elevator, Devon begins to have labor pains and Sarah tries to help. Devon refuses to have her baby in an elevator and asks Sarah to talk to her to keep her focused. Sarah admits her fear that her relationship with Joseph isn’t as much as she would like it to be and Devon admits that she fears Gage is slipping back into his old routine.

A frantic Gage shows up at the hospital in search of Devon. He runs into Elijah, who tells him where Devon is and when Gage arrives, he finds Devon with Sarah. An angry Devon asks him where he was the whole time. She tells him that she was trapped in the elevator with Sarah, and when Gage asks if everything is okay, Devon explains that it was Braxton Hicks. Gage says that he found a job and was at work, but Devon can tell that he is lying. She smells alcohol on his breath and proceeds to attack him, but Sarah holds her back. Elijah comes to help Gage out and Devon tells him that it is truly and finally over between them. Gage slips out of the room alone.

Szymon decides to try and make it up to Cayden by bringing him flowers, but when he shows up at the hospital, Cayden is having a private conversation with Drake Talbot and Drake is holding Cayden’s hand. Szymon flees and tells Joseph Lester that Cayden is cheating on him and Joseph urges Szymon to talk to Cayden. Meanwhile, Drake is admitting his feelings to Cayden and Cayden tells him that they can only be friends. He wants to make things work with Szymon. Drake understands and leaves and Sarah steps off of the elevator. Cayden admits to her that he wants to stay with Szymon, but can see how he could easily go with Drake because Szymon is so nasty to him lately. Szymon overhears this and misinterprets what Cayden says and accuses him of cheating and asks him to leave the hospital and Sarah is there to take Cayden away.

Szymon returns home to find that Cayden is not there. Joseph, who has accompanied Szymon, offers to stay with him for a little while and they have a beer together. Szymon realizes that with him and Cayden breaking up that he will have to find another place to live and Joseph offers his apartment. When Szymon asks Joseph why he would do that, Joseph begins to kiss Szymon. Meanwhile, Cayden admits to Sarah that he is going to focus on Szymon and stop worrying about everyone else’s problems, but everything changes when Cayden and Sarah walk in on Szymon and Joseph having sex. Cayden asks Szymon to move out.

2x18: "Take A Bow"

Sarah has a few choice words for Joseph’s fellow police officers to hear at the precinct. Joseph’s new partner Patrick O’Leary is both stunned and disgusted. A shamed Joseph tells her that she is better than this and storms off. Cecilia Nakamura takes the obviously drunk Sarah to get a cup of coffee while Szymon tries to repair what is left between him and Joseph, but Joseph wants no part of it and punches Szymon in the face when he touches him in public.

At the coffee shop, Sarah admits to Cecilia that she was never an angry person, but ever since what happened between Szymon and Joseph, all she can feel is anger. Cecilia tells her that she understands, she’s been in similar situations before and no one blames her for how she feels.

2x19: "Soul Deceiver"

Sarah tells Jesse that she is thinking about going back to school for photography. Jesse encourages her to do so. Jesse tells Sarah that things aren't adding up. Ryan doesn't know things about Julia. Sarah tells Jesse that she will try and get closer to Ryan for him. Serena warns Sarah that something dangerous is going to happen.

2x20: "Crazy"

Sarah has decided that she is going to try and get close to Ryan and goes to Xstatic to see if she is there. She realizes, too late, that she is in the wrong place at the wrong time and, while hiding, calls her grandmother for help. Meanwhile, Szymon seemingly walks right into a trap, but all isn't as it seems as Cecilia emerges and gets the upper hand on Gino, leaving Vinny wide open, but when Anthony reveals that he has Sarah, Szymon and Cecilia have to surrender.

Vinny is annoyed with Sarah Mulberry's crying and orders Anthony to kill her, but Mrs. Mulberry shows up and stops him. He realizes that Sarah is her granddaughter. He tells her that it's too bad that the both of them had to see this, but he can't have any witnesses, he has to kill Sarah and he has to kill her. Mrs. Mulberry tries to appeal to his humanity and reminds him about the boy he used to be, the one she used to babysit. He tells her that that boy disappeared a long time ago and as he gives the order to execute everyone, Mrs. Mulberry blurts out that Sarah is his daughter.

Vinny is angry with Mrs. Mulberry for lying to him about Sarah for all of these years. He tells her that he should kill her for lying to him. Sarah pleads with him not to do it. Vinny starts to talk to everyone about loyalty and then suddenly shoots Anthony Guzzetti in the head, labeling him as the traitor. In the resulting chaos, Sebby pulls out a gun and kills Vinny. He then turns his gun on Szymon and asks him to join him. He will take over his brother's business. He tells him that Gino was the real mole and that together, they can rule this town. Sebby is shocked when Gino reveals that he is an undercover cop and places Sebby under arrest.

Sarah is angry with Mrs. Mulberry for lying to her for her entire life and she moves out.